Docsity
Docsity

Prepare for your exams
Prepare for your exams

Study with the several resources on Docsity


Earn points to download
Earn points to download

Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan


Guidelines and tips
Guidelines and tips

Aristotle and Plutarch on the Role of Women in Ancient Sparta, Study notes of Classical Philology

Study questions for analyzing the roles of women in ancient sparta as portrayed in texts by aristotle and plutarch. Students are asked to compare and contrast their descriptions, consider the implications of spartan women's property ownership, and form a nuanced view of their behavior.

Typology: Study notes

Pre 2010

Uploaded on 08/16/2009

koofers-user-j4x
koofers-user-j4x 🇺🇸

5

(1)

10 documents

1 / 1

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Study Questions on Bad Spartan Women
Begin with the passage from Aristotle’s Politics. It’s a short but difficult passage, much like the
Foucault we read at the beginning of the semester. Go slowly and think carefully.
1. In discussing possible weaknesses in Sparta’s constitution Aristotle first considers slaves
(specifically the helots), then women. Is this conjunction incidental or significant? Why so?
2. The lawgiver that Aristotle mentions is Lycurgus. Compare the discussion of Lycurgus’ laws
from Plutarch that we read last time. How are the two descriptions different? How do you think
that is possible? Which do you believe?
3. The problems with Spartan women, according to Aristotle, stem from one source. What is it?
4. To what does Aristotle attribute the Spartal “laxness” regarding their women?
5. How did the disparity in landholdings arise in Sparta? How much did women own in Aris-
totle’s time? How exactly did the unequal ownership of property impair the military?
Go back and consider the portrayal of Lampito and Sparta in Aristophanes’ Lysistrata lines 80–
260 and 1026–1056.
6. Does the depiction (from a generation before Aristotle) mesh well with the description in the
Politics?
7. Are there any other Athenian stereotypes of Spartan women that you can extract?
Now review the Plutarch passages from last class.
8. What passages in Plutarch depict Spartan women negatively?
9. How can we reconcile the negative depictions with the very positive (?) descriptions of
Archidamia, Agesistrata, Chilonis, and Cratesicleia?
10. Try (like Plutarch) to form a nuanced view of female behavior in Sparta. What are the bene-
fits and dangers of their system?

Partial preview of the text

Download Aristotle and Plutarch on the Role of Women in Ancient Sparta and more Study notes Classical Philology in PDF only on Docsity!

Study Questions on Bad Spartan Women Begin with the passage from Aristotle’s Politics. It’s a short but difficult passage, much like the Foucault we read at the beginning of the semester. Go slowly and think carefully.

  1. In discussing possible weaknesses in Sparta’s constitution Aristotle first considers slaves (specifically the helots ), then women. Is this conjunction incidental or significant? Why so?
  2. The lawgiver that Aristotle mentions is Lycurgus. Compare the discussion of Lycurgus’ laws from Plutarch that we read last time. How are the two descriptions different? How do you think that is possible? Which do you believe?
  3. The problems with Spartan women, according to Aristotle, stem from one source. What is it?
  4. To what does Aristotle attribute the Spartal “laxness” regarding their women?
  5. How did the disparity in landholdings arise in Sparta? How much did women own in Aris- totle’s time? How exactly did the unequal ownership of property impair the military? Go back and consider the portrayal of Lampito and Sparta in Aristophanes’ Lysistrata lines 80– 260 and 1026–1056.
  6. Does the depiction (from a generation before Aristotle) mesh well with the description in the Politics?
  7. Are there any other Athenian stereotypes of Spartan women that you can extract? Now review the Plutarch passages from last class.
  8. What passages in Plutarch depict Spartan women negatively?
  9. How can we reconcile the negative depictions with the very positive (?) descriptions of Archidamia, Agesistrata, Chilonis, and Cratesicleia?
  10. Try (like Plutarch) to form a nuanced view of female behavior in Sparta. What are the bene- fits and dangers of their system?