


























Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Community
Ask the community for help and clear up your study doubts
Discover the best universities in your country according to Docsity users
Free resources
Download our free guides on studying techniques, anxiety management strategies, and thesis advice from Docsity tutors
A school's need to document and share student health information must be considered against the student's rights to confidentiality for sensitive services or ...
Typology: Study notes
1 / 34
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Overview
School nurses are privy to a great deal of intimate information about the students with whom they work. The increased number of children in schools with health and learning challenges has resulted in more than the traditional screening and immunization information in a student's health records.
A complex web of laws and standards of professional practice define the responsibilities and rights of parents, students, school health staff and other school staff in the creation, updating, maintenance, control of, access to, and disclosure of student health records. Education reforms, such as inclusion, accountability, charter schools, homeless and migrant education, and safe schools may mean that schools will need to create more data about their students and consider whether and how to share it, both exclusively within the school setting and between the school and other organizations. Budgetary realities mean that fewer schools have only one person with day- to-day “control” of all health information about students. Increasing electronic technology for encoding, storing, and transmitting of data has resulted in new and heightened privacy concerns.
A school’s need to document and share student health information must be considered against the student’s rights to confidentiality for sensitive services or unwarranted disclosure of personal information and the parent’s and student’s rights to know what is in a student’s record, to gain access to it for inspection or correction, and to control disclosure of that information.
This chapter discusses responsibilities of school staff in creating health records about a student, maintaining those records, and disclosing or sharing the information contained in those records. It also discusses the rights of parents and students in accessing these records and their rights to control release of these records.
School nurses may be the authors and/or custodians of many formal, legally mandated health records, such as Individualized Family Service Plans (IFSPs); Individualized Health Plans (IHPs), Individualized Emergency Plans, (IEPs), etc. Their files contain notes on individual students seen during the course of the school year, a student's medications, notes about the physical or mental health condition of a student or even a student’s parents, reasons for
Disclosure of student health information includes disclosures to the student, the student’s parents, school staff, and other non-school third parties
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
This section briefly describes the pertinent legislation and then goes through the "life stages" of a record, with the requirements of each particular law.
Privacy, Access and Disclosure
(^1) 20 USC §1232g; regulations are found in 34 CFR Part 99.
who have a specific and legitimate educational interest in the information. The school must maintain a written log of who accessed the records and when access occurs. 2
(^2) National Center for Educational Statistics (1997). Guidelines for protecting confidential student health information. Kent, OH: American School Health Association. 3 IDEA's regulations on confidentiality 34 CFR §§300.560-300.577 contain several references to FERPA. 4 34 CFR §§ 300.501 and 300.562.
School health records are considered to be part of a student’s educational record
FAPE - Free and Appropriate Public Education
FERPA- Family Educational Records Privacy Act
HIPAA- Health Information Portability and Accountability Act
IDEA- Individuals with Disabilities Educational Act
LRE – Least Restrictive Environment
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
guardian or who might be legally responsible for a child's welfare, such as a grandmother, stepparent, or foster parent.
(^5) Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996, Privacy Amendment Regulations, 45 CFR Parts 160 and 164, http://www.hhs.gov/ocr/hipaa/finalreg.html.
record, but not protected health information." 6
There are several instances in which HIPAA does impact schools. School based health centers, that are operated under the auspices of a hospital or health center must comply with the regulations that govern that organization and therefore must comply with HIPAA regulations. School districts that bill for Medicaid reimbursement must comply with HIPAA regulations because of the electronic dissemination of information from the school to billing agents and the state. And health care practitioners that share information with schools must comply with HIPAA requirements. This fact may lead to frustration on the part of schools when health care practitioners refuse to release information without the releases that they have in place. Sharing of immunization information, however, is not governed by HIPAA regulations. Schools are acting as a “public health authority” when they are statutorily required to track the immunization status of children at the school. HIPAA allows protected health information to
(^6) HIPAA regulations, which became effective in 2003, also do not apply to FERPA records designated as education records under Parts B, C, and D or the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA); Memorandum from. Family Policy Compliance Office, U.S. Department of Education. (February 2002).
The exclusion of school health records from HIPAA regulations is explained by the fact that FERPA already protects those records and no further protection is deemed necessary
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
The Life Stages of a School Health Record The life stage of a record includes its creation, its maintenance and storage, limitations to access of the record, and retention after the student leaves the school program_._
What is a Record? FERPA protects eligible students' privacy interests in "education records," which are defined as "those records, files, documents, and other materials which - (i) contain information directly related to a student; and (ii) are maintained by an educational agency or institution or by a person acting for such agency or institution.”^12 The rights under FERPA belong to the parents of students under the age of 18 at the elementary/ secondary level and transfer to the student when he or she becomes an "eligible” student at age 18.
Under FERPA and Colorado law , education records include information directly related to a student, which are maintained by the school in any recorded way, such as test scores, disciplinary records, transcripts, etc. They do not include records made by school personnel that are kept solely in their own possession and are not revealed to anyone
(^12) 20 USC §1232g(a)(4)(i) and (ii); see also 34 CFR § 99.3.
else. A school nurse’s personal notes or diary would not be an official school health record, unless the nurse shared them with others as part of her work. 13
Federal and state laws generally prohibit disclosure of information in the record without the consent of the parent or eligible student. There are exceptions. Disclosure without prior consent is permissible under limited circumstances:
other individuals.
(^13) 20 USC §1232g(4)(B).
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
In Colorado, if a school creates or collects medical or health records on a student, those records are considered the student's Cumulative Health Record (CHR), and they are part of the student's academic record. The CHR contains:
Who Creates School Health Records? Since school staff members other than the school nurse contribute to a student’s health needs, it follows that they could also contribute to a school health record. Staff who might contribute to the record could include education support professionals (including
(^14) Colorado Department of Education (2004). Record retention. http://www.cde.state.co.us/cdesped/nurseFA Q.asp
registered nurse, licensed practical nurse, nurses’ aide, classroom staff, health or therapist aide/technician); outside health provider; school psychologist; or school social worker. Because this pool of possible contributors is so wide, the school should have a clearly articulated system of how records are created and templates for reporting, so data is kept in a coherent fashion. For example, dates and names should be written in consistent formats, full name of recorders should be included in the record, and the school nurse should have overall responsibility for the records.
Maintenance and Storage of Records Storage and maintenance of records involve active records and historical records. The active records in the school nurse’s office, whether they are paper or electronic, need to be secure when not in use, but accessible when needed by staff. Lockable filing cabinets or computers are important, but maintaining these documents in a safe and monitorable location is also essential.^15
(^15) Policy Studies Associates, Inc. under contract to the Council of Chief State School Officers. Protecting the Privacy of Student Records Guidelines for Education Agencies National Center for Education Statistics: 1997 http://nces.ed.gov/pubs97/p97527/Sec5_txt.h tm
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
Under both federal and state laws, parents must be informed annually of their rights of access, ability to limit disclosures, and ability to have knowledge of third party access to their child’s records.
Who Else Can Have Access? Generally under FERPA a school cannot release information, other than “directory information” from a student's record without prior written permission from the parent or the eligible student. 21 Disclosure of “directory information” without prior written consent is allowed. “Directory information” is information that would not generally be considered harmful or an invasion of privacy if disclosed.
FERPA and Colorado laws allow disclosure of other information in a student’s records , without consent , in certain specific situations:
(^21) USC §1232g(b)(1) and (b)(2)(A); 34 CFR § 99.30.
School district staff members with access to student records must be identified by title and each student's file must include a record of access, on which all school staff members must sign whenever they consult that student's file. Staff that provide services within the area of a specific record so not have to sign it out each time they use the record. However if a school nurse accesses psychological records, she must sign and a psychologist must do the same when accessing health records. Schools must notify parents and eligible students annually of their rights. The actual means of notification (special letter, inclusion in a PTA bulletin, student handbook, or newspaper article) is left to the discretion of each school.
IDEA requires the school to maintain a record of all parties who obtain access to a child's
Directory Information:
Student name Address Telephone listing Electronic mail address Photograph Date and place of birth Major field of study Enrollment status (e.g., under- graduate or graduate; full-time or part-time) Participation in officially recognized activities and sports Weight and Height of members of the athletic teams Dates of attendance Degrees and awards received Previous educational agency or institution attended 34CFR §§ 99.31(a)(11); 99.
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Legal Considerations
educational records collected, maintained, or used under Part B of IDEA (with the exception of parents and authorized employees of the agency). This record should include the name of the person who accessed the records, the date, and the purpose for which the person was authorized to use the records (Section 300.563).
Colorado law specifically defines the content of a school request for written consent for the school district to release personally identifiable information concerning that parent's or legal guardian's child in education records other than directory information. The notice must include the specific records to be released, the reasons for the release, the identity of the person to whom the information will be released, the manner in which the release will be made (such as verbal, fax), and the parent’s right to review or receive a copy of the records to be released.^22 School nursing staff should maintain a log identifying those aside from regular health office staff, to whom access to the records has been given, when access occurred, and the specific records to which access was given.
(^22) CRS §22-1-123(6).
Transferring Records FERPA permits schools to transfer any and all education records, including disciplinary records, on a student who is transferring to another school.^23 School-generated health reports and assessments are routinely transferred along with the student's general records when a student transfers to a different school or district. The parent’s notification that a child is transferring is considered permission to transfer the child’s records to the new school.
Pertinent medical information that relates to the ability of a
such as a 504 plan, an IEP, a behavior plan, or a health care plan. There is no regulation that specifically addresses transferring health records outside a school district about a student from an outside health provider, but districts should be aware of potential problems if they are shared without parent
(^23) No Child Left Behind Act of 2001, § allows schools to transfer disciplinary records, with respect to a suspension or expulsion, by local educational agencies to any private or public elementary school or secondary school for any student who is enrolled or seeks, intends, or is instructed to enroll, on a full- or part-time basis, in the school."
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
A great deal of a school nurse’s time is spent around documents: nurse’s notes; immunization records; an alphabet soup of plans; medication records; third- party billing; case management notes; referral notes; prescription orders, etc. Accurate, timely documentation of nurse-student interactions promotes high quality student health services, advances the efficiency and effectiveness of the school and district health program, and creates a legal record. Legal and ethical considerations require school nurses to document care and keep personal information confidential and secure.
The following section poses some frequently asked questions.
What Records Should I Create? Standard nursing practice includes the following components: assessment, planning, implementation, and evaluation. 25
(^25) Minnesota Department of Health. (11/96). Minnesota School Health Guide. Section Two: Direct Services To Students. Chapter 6: Nursing Practice In The School Setting. http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/fh/mch/CA REweb/schoolhealth/chapter6.html.
prevent illness, and/or provide rehabilitation for the individual student or a given population.
Colorado state law is not prescriptive as to what a health record must contain, with the exception of an immunization record, and vision and hearing screening results. (For example, there is no Colorado law requiring an incident report to be written after a serious student injury.^26 ) Appropriate
documents for an active student health record could include, but are not limited to: 27
(^26) US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. State Level School Health Policies and Practices SHPSS Study Item 3. http://www.cdc.gov/nccdphp/dash/shpps/report _cards/pdf/colorado.pdf. 27 New Jersey Department of Education, Office of Educational Support Services (1997), School Health Services Guidelines 97 Topic
Student health information concerns two types of records: an active student health record and a cumulative health record. z The former is an active record for a child currently in a particular school. It could also be a file, containing multiple records, such as a health record, an IEP, a Health Plan, etc. z The latter Cumulative Health Record (CHR) is a compilation of the child’s total health experience while in one school: the CHR typically follows the child from school to school.
The rules about confidentiality and disclosure apply to both types of records.
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
7D: Student Health Records. pp. 104- http://www.state.nj.us/njded/parents/shg.pdf.
What About My Personal Notes? Under federal law, a school nurse’s personal notes or calendar log would be considered a protected educational record, only as long as the school nurse kept them in her sole possession and did not share the actual notes.^28 Current federal regulations define the “sole possession” exception: as records that are kept in the sole possession of the maker, are used only as a personal memory aid, and are not accessible or revealed to any other person except a temporary substitute for the maker of the record. Examples of this type of record would include written (handwritten, and possibly electronic) notes that are typically thrown away once the writer’s memory was jogged, such as a calendar note to check on a referral, or a “post-it” or notes about a transient situation that does not impact academic achievement or safety that because of its sensitivity could cause harm or embarrassment
to the student in the future. A personal calendar note would be a personal (not protected) document; a formal log or sign in sheet would be a protected document. While these documents do not have to be made available to parents, they
(^28) 20 USC 1232g(4)(B).
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
It is critical that the documentation display accurate descriptions of events, conditions, and actions
(^29) Harrigan,J.F., (2002). Overview of school health services publication. National Association of School Nurses. 30 Student Health Services and Records (JLC) revised, the Colorado Association of School Boards (CASBE) After consultations with the Colorado School Health Advisory Board and the State School Nurse Consultant; Schwab, NC, Panettieri, MJ & Bergren, MD (1998). Guidelines for School Nursing Documentation: Standards, Issues and Model s, 2nd Edition; National Association of School Nurses.
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
taken to minimize the danger that a student may suffer from misuse of a record in the future and to maximize the protection of the nurse and the district if a record is needed later to demonstrate that appropriate procedures were followed. Descriptions of student behavior and condition, backed up by whatever objective information may be available (such as vital signs, description of physical injury, etc.), comprise one of the most important documents in dealing with situations that may be controversial.^31
What About Electronic Records? Faxes, computers, hand held computers, and the Internet have revolutionized record keeping and sharing of information, but the same rules of confidentiality and security apply to computerized health records as hard copy. The school must assure protection of computerized health information from a list of potential problems, including: computer hacking or unauthorized access (intentional attack), natural disaster (including power surges); human error, viruses, computer crashes, inadvertent release (such as protecting an open computer file from being seen), and insecure transmission over the internet.
(^31) New Jersey SN Manual.
systems (tape, floppy, hard drive, or network drive) that are used scrupulously, consistently, and often. Staff using computers must have basic computer skills, such as knowledge about the necessity of frequent updating. The electrical hardware serving the computer should be sufficient to protect against power surges, electrical storms, use of other equipment, etc.
Some Ways to Promote Secure Maintenance of Automated Student Records
(^32 32) Schwab, NC, Panettieri, MJ & Bergren. National Association of School Nurses.10- CONFIDENTIALITY FAQs.doc – 6.
Some people use Social Security numbers as identifiers, other places have other ways of personally identifying people because they don’t want to use SS numbers. Before using a SS number on a record, you should make sure a) you don’t have a policy forbidding it and b) You have a good reason for using it.
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
What about keeping active health records? Health records should be kept in secured locations, separate from other student records, preferably in the school health office.^34 Written information should be labeled “confidential.” Electronic records should be saved on secure locations, such as password-protected files; and floppy discs and zip drives should also be kept in secured locations.
How do I protect confidentiality? The basic rule under FERPA and Colorado law is that medical diagnosis and other detailed health information should not be shared without informed consent from the student or the student’s parents except as permitted by law.
the student to injure another. 36
(^34) Colorado Department of Education. (date) Special Care for Health Records. 35 36 §19-3-304, CRS. §24-72-204(3)(d)(V)(e)(1), CRS.
services to all students and, therefore, not all staff needs to know the information on every student. Instead, a process should be implemented to identify individuals that have a legitimate educational interest and need to know the information in order for a student to functional optimally in the school setting.
The Colorado Department of Education recommends some basic rules, in addition to
(^37) Memorandum, CDE Commissioner of Education, May 2002 Confidentiality of School Health Records, http://www.cde.state.co.us/cdesped/download/ pdf/nur-Confidentiality.pdf. 38 NASSNC Position Statement National Association of State School Nurse Consultants. http://207.28.33.2/swp/tadkins/nassnc/NASSN C_confid.html#CONFIDENTIALITY
Personnel who have a legitimate NEED to KNOW – those employees, contract personnel or volunteers of an agency who provide direct services to the student or school officials with a legitimate educational interest as defined in the school records policy
Source: Schwab, N.C. & Gelfman, M.H.B. (2001) Legal issues in school health services: A resource for school administrators, school attorneys, school nurses. P. 307. Sunrise River Press, North Branch, MN.
DOCUMENTATION, RECORDKEEPING, and CONFIDENTIALITY
Documents and the Role of the School Nurse
Colorado law and FERPA, to assure privacy:
What about sensitive issues? The rules about maintaining confidentiality are stricter in health care settings than in schools with regard to certain sensitive health information, such as HIV status, mental health issues, pregnancy, abortion, and sexually transmitted diseases. In health care settings, medical information of this nature may not be released without the patient’s consent. These rules, however, do not apply in the school setting unless there are
(^39) Colorado Department of Education (2002). Confidentiality of school health records. http://www.cde.state.co.us/cdesped/download/ pdf/nur-Confidentiality.pdf
specific school district policies that address those issues. Ideally, when situations involving sensitive issues arise in schools, decisions about the sharing of information should be decided on a case-by-case basis, with consideration for the specific situation, the age and level of maturity of the student, and the student’s level of competency to manage the situation. School staff should always encourage a student to self-disclose to parents or guardians and may be instrumental in helping them do so.
A concern may arise if parents ask to see information in their child’s health record when that
record might contain information about sensitive issues that the student does not want the parent to see. The school nurse must make sure that, if documentation of such information is contained in the student’s record, the file can be compartmentalized in such a way that access to information about sensitive services can be protected from parental access until the student authorizes disclosure. (The advantages of electronic files for this type of information “layering” are obvious.)
FERPA and accompanying regulations define a “parent” as including both natural parents, custodial and non-custodial unless the school “has been