I
II
i Navp, ,/ro, y', DATE: 1
BSL2I2 _SECTION J
I - orJlz=s
i
1. P-g$ is about to.graduate from the University of'Miami Law Schooi. In April 2007, just a few weeks bbforg
graduation, he,purchases written materials from the book store (fo:-$g0Ql to assist him in studying for the bar exam,
which he will be taking later that summer. That.evening, he calls his fiiend Raul, who just'compl'eted his second year of
law school. Peter offerl6;iiiffir- ls to Raul (at a discount) aftei Peter takes thd bar exam, so that Raul ban use the.
mateiials to sfudy when he takes the bar exam. Raul is interested in savirig money, but *ilInot need the materials until he
takes the bar exam after he graduates. Accordingly, the parties reach an oral?heelqent on the telephone. The terms are
as follows: Raul will pay Peter'a total of $450. which will be due when Raul graduates in June 2008. at which time the
materials will be delivered to Raul. When Peter attempts to deliver the materials to Raul and collect the money upon'
Raul's graduation, Raul-refuses to accept the goods or to pay Peter, and clairhs that the oral agreement was unenforc€able.
' Peter then sues Raul. who wins and why? \ ", ( il .
Derision:6ir1)o. Raur ' o "'&^'^n" \' \v't.il'[Uo
:- r.-.,--'o. RauI fi n q[$\ t
"f \dil ^,.$$\ )^o,};({,*
UY I \ LNf)\$s\\\$':,\ \f '
t-YJ * 00', ac,t. YA)ol& ,.{
ffi'r*.d{ o/& also/s 44 ar'/ a7rlewi 4"?J/,:ttnl=l
m fp.a,ey're#* /€an fut & fu'2 *":U/z/q97t/d aru
/^zz ey4?//t445 /47//r,-/r2/ o4 an i-r/i/E iet/ n'/ &'//erv6neoa)4
/%47tu2 z'e
/dlet &//t 6&;/a le "f&er&N A"'A
Apnlication: ' '
zk tlrztq /a //,k asl /s atu/dlr t{e.a,z/ aTrye.rgn/ /e/reo /e*rz'd &z/
rs &6raeo/h, /.,&ra49 ro& a{ i* ,"fu'a,fuaad /cba gf -raa /'.r/nt/Z.e4
<"s-?/ a,-/ qd1aen/s. F,.147..v,np, un&r /g rz/Z a/'/ot't, //r/ a a4tad
*rra/ lz,pehQr,ne/ aii/lia at )ear- rlrs fu /* 12 *$iy- .&.g )4 lua gr*/ft3
t/ogz-4, */,?l ara /& pat,,6,-li4/ &sl ,n/ /a,/pfr4r>*an4. ro-s,Ur/* :d/;8:-
,"/ 44& ?'ooze le p-Br*e} 4rr$rh a /&a /i' /4 ats ,{ A/& aa/-rt%
€le s4€.& { f.r*a?. f-".// p./nta,66 ,ertry a f{ re u&& ,*v&"{/7rt
&, fuen ,ryQrM /o {t;s as€ /4o /{'4/e a*{^r,'/a 6a fu&/a af
Ouestion One
ts
