












Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Community
Ask the community for help and clear up your study doubts
Discover the best universities in your country according to Docsity users
Free resources
Download our free guides on studying techniques, anxiety management strategies, and thesis advice from Docsity tutors
The Vermont model for continuous improvement involves planning, testing, and analyzing changes for educational improvement using PDSA cycles. guidance on conducting PDSA cycles, including data collection, testing changes, and deciding to adopt, adapt, or abandon ideas. The PDSA Toolkit is recommended for schools and school systems engaged in this process.
Typology: Schemes and Mind Maps
1 / 20
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!
- Page 2 of
PDSA Toolkit Page 4 of 20
Plan-Do-Study-Act Worksheet
Briefly describe the test:
How will you know that this change idea is an improvement?
What do you predict will happen?
List the tasks necessary to complete this test (What)
Person responsible (Who)
When Where
Type of Data What data will be collected and what tool will be used for the measurement? Process Measures - Measures how well a change idea is implemented.
Outcome Measures - Measures if the change idea achieved its goal.
School: Test Date and Timeframe:
Prioritized SMART Goal:
Change idea to test:
PDSA Toolkit Page 5 of 20
( Upload data or link to data in this section ) Test the changes. Collect the data for:
Was the cycle carried out as planned? What happened during the testing phase?
What did you observe that was surprising?
What were the results? Did the results match your prediction(s)?
What did you learn?
□ Adopt: Select changes to implement on a larger scale, develop an implementation plan, and
plan for sustainability
□ Adapt: Improve the change and continue testing plan. What plans/changes are you going to
make for your next test?
□ Abandon: Discard this change idea and try a different one.
PDSA Toolkit Page 7 of 20
While conducting a comprehensive needs assessment, during phase 1 of the continuous improvement process, your team developed a working theory of improvement and driver diagram. A Working Theory of Improvement describes the structures and processes that the team believes need to be changed to meet an improvement goal, as well as, specific actions to create these changes (Provost & Bennett, 2015).
The Driver Diagram is a method for organizing your Theory of Improvement and can be completed using the information collected during the comprehensive needs assessment process. It becomes a record of learning and a roadmap for intervention. Theories can change based on testing each change idea and learning from the experiences.
A driver diagram shows the relationship between the overall SMART goal of your improvement project, the primary drivers that directly relate to achieving the goal, the secondary drivers that are components of the primary drivers, and specific change ideas to test for each secondary driver. (IHI QI Essential Toolkit: Driver Diagram, 2017)
The driver diagram is where you will determine which change ideas to test as you complete PDSA cycles you will update the driver diagram accordingly based on the data collected and decisions made about how to move forward (e.g. adopt, adapt, or abandon).
PDSA Toolkit Page 8 of 20
Those closest to implementing the change idea for each PDSA should be involved with each step of the PDSA process.
Teachers and Coaches:
Principals and Coaches:
Curriculum Directors/Superintendents:
PDSA Toolkit Page 10 of 20
Typically, Change Ideas originate from:
PDSA cycles conducted during the testing phase of the continuous improvement process are for the purpose of testing small scale changes to build confidence in their efficacy prior to full implementation and scale. PDSA cycles conducted during the implementation phase are for the purpose of fully implementing the agreed upon changes across contexts (once confidence in their efficacy is built during the testing phase). ) There is NO expectation regarding the number of PDSAs to complete or due dates for completion, as it is determined by local data and context.
Determining an appropriate “grain size” for the change idea being tested is important. An appropriate testable grain size relies on determining specific actions and behaviors, is measurable, and can be easily replicated by more than one person at a time with consistency. Change ideas that are too small can waste time and resources. Change ideas that are too big are difficult to test efficiently and effectively.
A one-time professional development workshop or course.
Testing and implementing instructional strategies learned at a professional development workshop or course. An instructional coach Coaching cycles to help teachers implement or improve a specific instructional strategy. Trauma-informed teaching Testing the lesson planning protocols developed by the instructional leadership team and behavior specialist team e.g., the specific instructional practice/intervention…
PDSA Toolkit Page 11 of 20
The first step of the PDSA cycle is to make a Plan by assigning tasks, roles, and due dates. In this step you and your team will also make a prediction(s) about what you think will happen by implementing the change idea and determine how you will measure the success of the change idea both while you are conducting the test and after the test is complete.
Briefly describe the test: Summarize what your change idea is and how you plan to test it. How will you know that this change idea is an improvement? Describe the process measures, outcome measures, and tools you will use to determine whether the change idea tested was an improvement. Sentence Starter: We will know that this change idea is an improvement because, teachers will…. students will…. What do you predict will happen? Write down your prediction or predictions about what teacher and student actions or behaviors you believe will happen or hope to see by implementing this change idea. The predictions need to be measurable and observable to determine whether they were met at the end of the test. Sentence Starter: We predict that teachers will……. We predict that students will……
Using the table below map out the necessary tasks needed to complete the test, identify who is responsible for completing the task, when the task should happen, and where. Be sure to communicate this plan to everyone involved in testing the change idea. List the tasks necessary to complete this test (What)
Person responsible (Who)
When Where
To determine the effectiveness of a change idea, it is important to identify methods to assess progress and monitor for unintended consequences along the way. Two measurement types can be used to maximize the effectiveness and efficiency of your team’s continuous improvement process.
PDSA Toolkit Page 13 of 20
In the Do phase of PDSA you will carry out the test as planned and collect the data identified in the plan phase. Be sure to pay attention and make note of any unexpected or unintended results that arise from testing the change idea.
( Upload data or link to data in this section ) Test the changes. Collect the data for:
In the Study phase of PDSA you will analyze the data you collected during the Do phase. We recommend using a protocol for analyzing and synthesizing data with your team. Below is a protocol you can use. You can use any from the links below or you develop your own protocol.
Before you begin:
Links to data analysis protocols:
PDSA Toolkit Page 14 of 20
Was the cycle carried out as planned? What happened during the testing phase? Explain what happened during the testing phase and whether the test was carried out as planned or if changes were made and why. Sometimes people are not on the same page about their roles and responsibilities and it is discovered during or after the test that different people were conducting the test differently. Include that information in this section. What did you observe that was surprising? Based on your balancing measures (see DO Section) what unexpected results, if any, presented themselves while testing the change idea? What were the results? Did the results match your prediction(s)? State the results of the data analysis and explain how they relate to your prediction(s). What did you learn? Discuss any reflections the group had about the process, what worked well and why, what did not work and why, realizations and a-ha moments while conducting the test, or any other lessons learned from testing the change idea. This reflection will help determine which direction to take in the next step, Act.
In the Act phase of PDSA the team will decide whether to adopt the change idea based on the data analysis conducted in the Study phase, abandon the change idea, or adapt the change idea and continue testing.
□ Adopt: Select changes to test on a larger scale, develop an implementation plan, and plan for
sustainability. Discuss the implementation plan that will be used for broadening the scale of the change
idea to ensure that is done with fidelity.
□ Adapt: Modify the change and continue testing plan. What plans/changes are you going to make for your next test? Using the data analysis from the study phase determine what changes and improvements the team can make to the initial idea and outline a plan for how the team can test this new adapted change idea.
□ Abandon: discard this change idea and try a different one. Explain the reasoning behind
abandoning this change idea. Choose a new change idea to test from the driver diagram and explain the
decision behind choosing the new change idea.
PDSA Toolkit Page 16 of 20
Balancing Measure: Used to test for unintended consequences of improvements (IHI, 2017).
Baseline Data: The initial performance data taken on a student; often the median score of three baseline data points or perception/survey data. The baseline serves as the reference point for all future data collection.
Benchmark (Periodic/Interim) Assessments: Assessments used to gather data several times a year and monitor students’ progress with respect to expected (benchmark) performance, over time.
Benchmarks : Content or developmental standards (levels, cut scores, targets, etc.) that describe sequences of growth that can be monitored over time. Usually measured three times per year (fall, winter, spring).
Change Idea: Evidence based actions for improvement that are related directly to secondary drivers and are intended to have positive outcomes toward meeting the goal.
Comprehensive Needs Assessment (CNA) : A formal process for determining gaps between current conditions and desired outcomes. Needs assessments are used to identify goals for continuous improvement.
Continuous Improvement: An ongoing process of improving school practice based on assessed needs and informed by data. Often this process includes rapid learning cycles / Plan- Do-Study-Act Cycles.
Data-Based Decision Making: The ongoing process of analyzing and evaluating student data to inform educational decisions, including, but not limited to, approaches in instruction, intervention, allocation of resources, development of policy, movement within a multi-level system, and disability identification.
Driver: The various components of the system believed to have the greatest influence on your problem/goal.
Driver Diagram: The Driver Diagram is a method for organizing your Theory of Improvement and can be completed using the information collected during the comprehensive needs assessment process, becoming a record of learning and a roadmap for intervention. A driver diagram shows the relationship between the overall SMART goal of your improvement project, the primary drivers that directly relate to achieving the goal, the secondary drivers that are components of the primary drivers, and specific change ideas to test for each secondary driver. (IHI QI Essential Toolkit: Driver Diagram, 2017)
Improvement Science: The science of determining which improvement strategies work best, based strongly on evidence. http://www.carnegiefoundation.org/our-ideas/
PDSA Toolkit Page 17 of 20
Local Educational Agency (LEA): Districts and Supervisory Unions
Outcomes/Summative Assessment: Assessments that help teachers to evaluate and verify learning over time and may aid teachers in planning future instruction, informing classroom decisions (i.e. potential use of groupings), evaluating curricular changes, and making school wide decisions regarding curriculum and instruction.
Outcome Measure: The measure of the intended result of your change idea.
Primary Driver: Broad areas and components of the system that have the greatest influence on the problem/goal.
Process Measure: The measure used to determine whether the successful implementation of a change idea is occurring before outcomes are known. These strategies can be monitored formatively and approaches to change can be revised quickly (IHI, 2017).
Progress Monitoring (see also Benchmark and Formative): Data used to frequently check student progress towards success. Progress monitoring is used to assess students’ academic or behavioral performance and evaluate the effectiveness of instruction. Progress monitoring procedures can be used with individual students or an entire class.
Secondary Driver: Specific practices or components within identified primary drivers that influence a problem/goal.
SMART Goal: Goals for improvement should be specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, and timebound describing what will be improved, by how much, by when, and for what/whom.
Theory of Improvement: A plan outlining actions necessary to achieve desired changes to reach your goal. It is usually written as an “If-Then” statement and/or displayed in a driver diagram. A Theory of Improvement describes the structures and processes that the team believes need to be changed in order to meet an improvement goal, as well as, specific actions to create these changes (Provost & Bennett, 2015).
PDSA Toolkit Page 19 of 20
9.6.18 Conference Room
PLAN- Data Collection Type of Data What data will be collected and what tool will be used for the measurement? Process Measures - Measures how well a change practice is implemented.
Test the changes. Collect the data.
Record data:
STUDY: Was the cycle carried out as planned? What happened during the testing phase?
What did you observe that was surprising?
PDSA Toolkit Page 20 of 20
What were the results? Did the results match your prediction(s)?
What did you learn?
Decide to Adopt, Adapt, or Abandon
X Adopt: Select changes to implement on a larger scale and develop and implementation plan and plan for sustainability.
□ Adapt: Improve the change and continue testing plan. What plans/changes are you going to make for your next test?
□ Abandon: discard this change idea and try a different one