Docsity
Docsity

Prepare for your exams
Prepare for your exams

Study with the several resources on Docsity


Earn points to download
Earn points to download

Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan


Guidelines and tips
Guidelines and tips

Emily Dickinson's 'Success is counted sweetest' - Understanding Victory and Defeat, Slides of Poetry

An analysis of emily dickinson's poem '#67' titled 'success is counted sweetest'. The analysis explores the idea of compensation and the superiority of defeat to victory, arguing that both defeat and victory have their own merits and drawbacks. The document also discusses dickinson's use of desire and renunciation in her poetry, and how she found delight in the objects of her longing, even if they were distant or moving away.

What you will learn

  • What role does desire and renunciation play in Emily Dickinson's poetry?
  • What is the main idea of Emily Dickinson's poem 'Success is counted sweetest'?
  • How does the dying soldier in the poem view victory differently than the victors?

Typology: Slides

2021/2022

Uploaded on 09/12/2022

electraxx
electraxx 🇺🇸

4.3

(12)

239 documents

1 / 2

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
Emily Dickinson
(1830-1886)
#67 (c.1859)
Success is counted sweetest
By those who ne’er succeed.
To comprehend a nectar
Requires sorest need.
Not one of all the purple Host
Who took the Flag today
Can tell the definition
So clear of Victory
As he defeated dying
On whose forbidden ear
The distant strains of triumph
Burst agonized and clear!
ANALYSIS
“Once an object has been magnified by desire, it cannot be wholly possessed by appetite…. The effect
of intense desiring is to render any finite satisfaction disappointing…. Certainly Emily Dickinson’s critics
are right in calling this poem an expression of the idea of compensationof the idea that every evil confers
some balancing good, that through bitterness we learn to appreciate the sweet, that “Water is taught by
thirst.’ The defeated and dying soldier of this poem is compensated by a greater awareness of the meaning
of victory than the victors themselves can have: he can comprehend the joy of success through its polar
contrast to his own despair.
The poem surely does say that; yet it seems to me that there is something further implied. On a first
reading, we are much impressed with the wretchedness of the dying soldier’s lot, and an improved
understanding of the nature of victory may seem small compensation for defeat and death; but the more one
ponders this poem the likelier it grows that Emily Dickinson is arguing against the superiority of defeat to
victory, of frustration to satisfaction, and of anguished comprehension to mere possession. What do the
victors have but victory, a victory which they cannot fully savor or clearly define? They have paid for their
triumph by a sacrifice of awareness; a material gain has cost them a spiritual loss. For the dying soldier, the
case is reversed: defeat and death are attended by an increase of awareness, and material loss had led to
spiritual gain. Emily Dickinson would think that the better bargain….
Emily Dickinson elected the economy of desire, and called her privation good, rendering it positive by
renunciation. And so she came to live in a huge world of delectable distances. Far-off worlds like ‘Brazil’
or ‘Circasian’ appear continually in her poems as symbols of things distanced by loss or renunciation, yet
infinitely prized and yearned-for. So identified in her mind are distance and delight that, when ravished by
the sight of a hummingbird in her garden, she calls in ‘the mail from Tunis.’ And not only are the objects of
her desire distant; they are also very often moving away, their sweetness increasing in proportion to their
remoteness…. ‘Heaven,’ she said, ‘is what I cannot reach.’ At times it seems that there is nothing in her
world but her own soul, with its attendant abstractions, and, at a vast remove, the inscrutable Heaven….
‘Enough is of so vast a sweetness, I suppose it never occurs, only pathetic counterfeits.’ The writer of that
sentence could not invest her longings in any finite object.”
Richard Wilbur
“Sumptuous Destitution”
Emily Dickinson: Three Views
pf2

Partial preview of the text

Download Emily Dickinson's 'Success is counted sweetest' - Understanding Victory and Defeat and more Slides Poetry in PDF only on Docsity!

Emily Dickinson

#67 (c.1859)

Success is counted sweetest By those who ne’er succeed. To comprehend a nectar Requires sorest need.

Not one of all the purple Host Who took the Flag today Can tell the definition So clear of Victory

As he defeated – dying – On whose forbidden ear The distant strains of triumph Burst agonized and clear!

ANALYSIS

“Once an object has been magnified by desire, it cannot be wholly possessed by appetite…. The effect of intense desiring is to render any finite satisfaction disappointing…. Certainly Emily Dickinson’s critics are right in calling this poem an expression of the idea of compensation—of the idea that every evil confers some balancing good, that through bitterness we learn to appreciate the sweet, that “Water is taught by thirst.’ The defeated and dying soldier of this poem is compensated by a greater awareness of the meaning of victory than the victors themselves can have: he can comprehend the joy of success through its polar contrast to his own despair.

The poem surely does say that; yet it seems to me that there is something further implied. On a first reading, we are much impressed with the wretchedness of the dying soldier’s lot, and an improved understanding of the nature of victory may seem small compensation for defeat and death; but the more one ponders this poem the likelier it grows that Emily Dickinson is arguing against the superiority of defeat to victory, of frustration to satisfaction, and of anguished comprehension to mere possession. What do the victors have but victory, a victory which they cannot fully savor or clearly define? They have paid for their triumph by a sacrifice of awareness; a material gain has cost them a spiritual loss. For the dying soldier, the case is reversed: defeat and death are attended by an increase of awareness, and material loss had led to spiritual gain. Emily Dickinson would think that the better bargain….

Emily Dickinson elected the economy of desire, and called her privation good, rendering it positive by renunciation. And so she came to live in a huge world of delectable distances. Far-off worlds like ‘Brazil’ or ‘Circasian’ appear continually in her poems as symbols of things distanced by loss or renunciation, yet infinitely prized and yearned-for. So identified in her mind are distance and delight that, when ravished by the sight of a hummingbird in her garden, she calls in ‘the mail from Tunis.’ And not only are the objects of her desire distant; they are also very often moving away, their sweetness increasing in proportion to their remoteness…. ‘Heaven,’ she said, ‘is what I cannot reach.’ At times it seems that there is nothing in her world but her own soul, with its attendant abstractions, and, at a vast remove, the inscrutable Heaven…. ‘Enough is of so vast a sweetness, I suppose it never occurs, only pathetic counterfeits.’ The writer of that sentence could not invest her longings in any finite object.” Richard Wilbur “Sumptuous Destitution” Emily Dickinson: Three Views

(Amherst 1960)