Docsity
Docsity

Prepare for your exams
Prepare for your exams

Study with the several resources on Docsity


Earn points to download
Earn points to download

Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan


Guidelines and tips
Guidelines and tips

Chronic Sorrow in Elderly Indonesians following Loss of Partner, Study notes of Nursing

This study examines chronic sorrow in elderly Indonesians who have lost their partner, with a focus on the pervasiveness, permanence, and periodicity of the condition. The research was conducted in District Tegallalang, Gianyar regency, Bali, and used the Burke/Eakes Chronic Sorrow Assessment Tool and the Multidimensional Body-Self Relations Questionnaire-Appearance Scale to measure chronic sorrow and self-image, respectively. The results showed that the majority of the 255 participants experienced chronic sorrow at the pervasive state, and that certain sociodemographic characteristics and personality types were associated with different stages of chronic sorrow.

What you will learn

  • What is the distribution of chronic sorrow stages among elderly Indonesians who have lost their partner?
  • What is the relationship between self-image and chronic sorrow in elderly Indonesians who have lost their partner?

Typology: Study notes

2021/2022

Uploaded on 03/31/2022

strawberry3
strawberry3 🇺🇸

4.6

(38)

394 documents

1 / 6

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
The 9th International Nursing Conference 2018 603
“Nurses at The Forefront in Transforming Cre, Science, and research
Chronic Sorrow At The Elderly Who Has Lost Partner With
Pakurenan Culture (Extended Family) In Indonesia
I Ketut Andika Priastana1, Joni Haryanto1, Suprajitno2
1Faculty of Nursing, Airlangga University, Surabaya, East Java, Indonesia
2Stikes Patria Husada, Blitar, East Java, Indonesia
iketutandikapriastana@gmail.com
Keywords: Chronic Sorrow, Elderly, Extended Family.
Abstract: Background: Chronic sorrow is the ongoing disparity resulting from a loss characterized by pervasiveness
and permanence. Symptoms of grief can occur and may recur periodically and potentially become
progressive. One of the causes of chronic sorrow in the elderly is losing a partner. In Indonesia, the elderly
who suffered a loss of partner reached 38.17% of the total elderly population in Indonesia in 2015. As many
as 36.69% of them are lossing of partner due to death. One of the provinces in Indonesia, Bali, has a unique
culture called Pakurenan (extended family) which makes the elderly live with their families. Methods: This
descriptive study was conducted on 255 elderly aged 60 to 82 years who experienced chronic sorrow due
their loss of partner. Chronic sorrow is judged base on the Burke/Eakes Chronic Sorrow Assessment Tool.
Results: The results showed that 49% of elderly had chronic sorrow at pervasive stage, 28.3% at permanent
stage, 18.4% at periodic stage and 4.3% at potentially progressive stage. Conclusion: The image of chronic
sorrow in the elderly can explain that the chronic sorrow is quite high experienced by the elderly who
suffered a loss of partner that need to be handled comprehensively. Elderly with Pakurenan culture
(extended family) shows a result of mild chronic sorrow.
1 BACKGROUND
Chronic sorrow is the ongoing disparity resulting
from a loss characterized by pervasiveness and
permanence. Symptoms of grief can occur and may
recur periodically and potentially become
progressive (Eakes et al. 1998). One of the causes of
chronic sorrow in the elderly is losing a partner. In
Indonesia, the elderly who suffered a loss of partner
reached 38.17% of the total elderly population in
Indonesia in 2015. As many as 36.69% of them were
lossing of partner due to death. There is more
women elderly with widowed status (56.04%) than
the men elderly. This happened due to the higher life
expectancy of women compared to men’s life
expectancy, so that the percentage of women elderly
with widowed status is higher than the men elderly
(Kementerian Kesehatan RI 2016).
One of the provinces in Indonesia, Bali, has a
unique culture related to residency called Pakurenan.
Pakurenan is kuren (kuren in Balinese term known
as family unit) who still have kinship, settling and
living together within one yard (extended family)
(Adnyani 2016). This culture keeps the elderly to
live with their families.
Loss of partner is one of the triggers of
psychological disorders in the form of recurring
sadness. Elderly who experienced a loss of their
partner tend to show increased symptoms of
depression, which may reach a certain degree of
severity (Sikorski et al. 2014; Tseng et al. 2017).
Other studies also support this statement, indicating
that the elderly who experienced a significantly
greater loss of partner also experienced depression
disorders such as symptoms of loneliness, sadness,
mood depression and loss of appetite (Fried et al.
2015). In addition, the loss of a partner has a
tendency to cause impaired cognitive function in the
domain of executive at the elderly. This disorder is
more common among women (Vidarsdottir et al.
2014).
Psychological disorders arising from loss of a
partner also cause functional impairment in the
elderly (Hajek et al. 2017). In addition to
psychological disorders, due to loss of the partner
also indirectly affects the physical of elderly, which
is the occurrence of weight loss. Uncertain events,
pf3
pf4
pf5

Partial preview of the text

Download Chronic Sorrow in Elderly Indonesians following Loss of Partner and more Study notes Nursing in PDF only on Docsity!

The 9th International Nursing Conference 2018 603

“Nurses at The Forefront in Transforming Cre, Science, and research”

Chronic Sorrow At The Elderly Who Has Lost Partner With

Pakurenan Culture (Extended Family) In Indonesia

I Ketut Andika Priastana

1

, Joni Haryanto

1

, Suprajitno

2 (^1) Faculty of Nursing, Airlangga University, Surabaya, East Java, Indonesia (^2) Stikes Patria Husada, Blitar, East Java, Indonesia iketutandikapriastana@gmail.com

Keywords: Chronic Sorrow, Elderly, Extended Family.

Abstract: Background: Chronic sorrow is the ongoing disparity resulting from a loss characterized by pervasiveness and permanence. Symptoms of grief can occur and may recur periodically and potentially become progressive. One of the causes of chronic sorrow in the elderly is losing a partner. In Indonesia, the elderly who suffered a loss of partner reached 38.17% of the total elderly population in Indonesia in 2015. As many as 36.69% of them are lossing of partner due to death. One of the provinces in Indonesia, Bali, has a unique culture called Pakurenan (extended family) which makes the elderly live with their families. Methods: This descriptive study was conducted on 255 elderly aged 60 to 82 years who experienced chronic sorrow due their loss of partner. Chronic sorrow is judged base on the Burke/Eakes Chronic Sorrow Assessment Tool. Results: The results showed that 49% of elderly had chronic sorrow at pervasive stage, 28.3% at permanent stage, 18.4% at periodic stage and 4.3% at potentially progressive stage. Conclusion: The image of chronic sorrow in the elderly can explain that the chronic sorrow is quite high experienced by the elderly who suffered a loss of partner that need to be handled comprehensively. Elderly with Pakurenan culture (extended family) shows a result of mild chronic sorrow.

1 BACKGROUND

Chronic sorrow is the ongoing disparity resulting

from a loss characterized by pervasiveness and

permanence. Symptoms of grief can occur and may

recur periodically and potentially become

progressive (Eakes et al. 1998). One of the causes of

chronic sorrow in the elderly is losing a partner. In

Indonesia, the elderly who suffered a loss of partner

reached 38.17% of the total elderly population in

Indonesia in 2015. As many as 36.69% of them were

lossing of partner due to death. There is more

women elderly with widowed status (56.04%) than

the men elderly. This happened due to the higher life

expectancy of women compared to men’s life

expectancy, so that the percentage of women elderly

with widowed status is higher than the men elderly

(Kementerian Kesehatan RI 2016).

One of the provinces in Indonesia, Bali, has a

unique culture related to residency called Pakurenan.

Pakurenan is kuren (kuren in Balinese term known

as family unit) who still have kinship, settling and

living together within one yard (extended family)

(Adnyani 2016). This culture keeps the elderly to

live with their families.

Loss of partner is one of the triggers of

psychological disorders in the form of recurring

sadness. Elderly who experienced a loss of their

partner tend to show increased symptoms of

depression, which may reach a certain degree of

severity (Sikorski et al. 2014; Tseng et al. 2017).

Other studies also support this statement, indicating

that the elderly who experienced a significantly

greater loss of partner also experienced depression

disorders such as symptoms of loneliness, sadness,

mood depression and loss of appetite (Fried et al.

2015). In addition, the loss of a partner has a

tendency to cause impaired cognitive function in the

domain of executive at the elderly. This disorder is

more common among women (Vidarsdottir et al.

Psychological disorders arising from loss of a

partner also cause functional impairment in the

elderly (Hajek et al. 2017). In addition to

psychological disorders, due to loss of the partner

also indirectly affects the physical of elderly, which

is the occurrence of weight loss. Uncertain events,

604 The 9th International Nursing Conference 2018 “Nurses at The Forefront in Transforming Care, Science, and research”

such as mourning, some show deteriorating health

conditions. The negative result of this incident poses

a greater risk for elderly to be independent and at

least enjoy satisfactory quality of life. When it

comes to weight loss, especially unintentional

weight loss, the effect may be detrimental (Mercan

et al. 2016).

This study aims to identify the chronic sorrow of

the elderly who loss of partner in Pakurenan culture

in Indonesia and its relation to the characteristics of

respondents such as age, gender, personality type,

subjective health, self-ideal, self-image and self-

esteem.

2 METHODS

This study uses descriptive research design with

survey method. The populations in this study are

elderly who experienced chronic sorrow due to loss

partner in District Tegallalang, Gianyar regency,

Bali. The populations in this study were taken from

two villages located in Tegallalang Sub-District,

Tegallalang Village and Keliki Village. The samples

in this study were taken with simple random

sampling based on power analysis as many as 255

respondents aged 60-82 years, losing partner less

than 48 months. Exclusion criteria are: elderly with

mental disorders or other chronic diseases such as

dementia, Parkinson, stroke and diabetes mellitus

(based on medical history); elderly outside the

community (e.g. hospitals, nursing home and

others).

The instrument used was the Burke/Eakes

Chronic Sorrow Assessment Tool for measuring

chronic sorrow (Eakes et al. 1998). Instrument of

Littaeur Personality Type used to measure

personality type of respondent (Littauer 1992). The

12-Item Short Form Health Survey (SF-12) to

measure health perceptions (Ware et al. 1995). The

Self-Attributes Questionnaire – Self Ideal Sub-Scale

for self-idealizing measure (Pelham & Swann 1989).

The Multidimensional Body-Self Relations

Questionnaire-Appearance Scale (MBSRQ-AS) for

measuring self-image of respondents (Cash et al.

1986). Rosenberg Self-Esteem which used to

measure respondents’ self-esteem (Rosenberg 1965).

3 RESULTS

The total of 255 elderly who experienced chronic

sorrow due to loss of partners aged 60-82 years old

with female gender of 69% (n=176) and male by

31% (n=79). The results of the study of Burke/Eakes

Chronic Sorrow Assessment Tool showed that the

majority chronic sorrow characteristics at the

pervasive state was 49% (n=125), at a permanent

state was 28.3% (n=72), at a periodic state was

18.4% (n=47) and at potentially progressive state

was 4.3% (n=11).

3.1 Personality Type

The result of study using Littaeur Personality Type

Instrument showed that most personality that is

choleric equal to 22.7% (n=58), followed by

phlegmatic which is equal to 22.7% (n=58),

sanguine equal to 21.6% (n=55) and melancholy that

is equal to 21.2% (n=54).

Table 1 : Personality Type.

Personality Type F % Choleric 88 34. Sanguine 55 21. Phlegmatic 58 22. Melancholic 54 21. 255 100

Table 2 : Subjective Health.

Subjective Health F % Good 152 59. Poor 103 40. 255 100

Table 3 : Self-Ideal.

Self-Ideal F % Positive 150 58. Negative 105 41. 255 100

Table 4 : Self-Image

Self-Image F % Positive 158 62 Negative 97 38 255 100

Table 5 : Self-Esteem

Self-Esteem F % Positive 170 66. Negative 85 33. 255 100

606 The 9th International Nursing Conference 2018 “Nurses at The Forefront in Transforming Care, Science, and research”

and the lowest at potentially progressive state at

2.5% (n=2).

Personality type of choleric, sanguine, and

phlegmatic are also more at pervasive state and

lowest at potentially progressive state. The

difference is found at the periodic state (n=17) is

more than the permanent state (n=13).

Good subjective health shows that there is more

at pervasive state, 77% (n=117) and the lowest at

periodic condition, which is 3.3% (n=5) and there is

no potentially progressive state (n=0). Poor

subjective health shows that is more at permanent

and periodic conditions with the same amount,

40.8% (n=42) and the lowest at pervasive state,

7.7% (n=8).

Positive self-ideal shows more at pervasive state,

at 74% (n=111) and the lowest is at periodic state,

4.7% (n=7) and there is no potentially progressive

state (n=0). Negative self-ideal shows that there is

more at permanent and periodic condition with equal

number of 38.1% (n=40) and the lowest is at

potentially progressive state of 10.5% (n=11).

Positive self-image shows more at pervasive

state, 73.4% (n=116) and the lowest at periodic

condition which equals to 7% (n=10). Negative self-

image shows at permanent state with equal number

that is equal to 42.3% (n=41) and the lowest at 9.3%

(n=9) at pervasive state.

Positive self-esteem showed more number at

pervasive state of 69.4% (n=118) and the lowest at

potentially progressive state of 0.6% (n=1). Negative

self-esteem showed more percentage in periodic

state with the same amount which is equal to 41.2%

(n=35) and the lowest at pervasive state which

equals to 8.2% (n=7).

4 DISCUSSIONS

Pervasive chronic sorrow is felt in the early days

of loss where the feeling of sadness begins to

emerge and it is so deep. The next stage of chronic

sorrow will enter at a permanent stage that is felt

throughout their life but has not shown any

significant influence. In the third stage, chronic

sorrow will periodically appear especially on very

strong trigger events. Poor management will result

in the falling of chronic sorrow at progressive state

that caused disturbances to activities (Eakes et al.

1998). Study shows more events at pervasive state

which is 49%, experienced more in the early loss of

partner.

Gender of the elderly who suffers from losing

affects the elderly response to loss of partner. Men

are shown to be able to maintain physical health

better than women when they experience a loss of

partner (Fry 2001). In addition to gender, age also

greatly affects the preparedness of the elderly to face

with the pressure of losing a partner. The older the

elderly are judged to be better in the period of

mourning (Brenn & Ytterstad 2016). This is similar

to the results of study that show women elderly

experience chronic sorrow more than the men

elderly. Older age also shows better chronic sorrow

conditions than younger ages.

Personality is a typical pattern of a person in

thinking, feeling and behaving which relatively

stable and predictable (Dorland 2012). Personality is

also the total number of congenital or hereditary

trends with various influences from environment and

education that shape the psychological condition of a

person and influence his attitude toward life (Weller

2009). Florence Littaeur developed four personality

types: choleric, sanguine, phlegmatic, and

melancholy. Each personality type has an influence

on one’s attitude and way of thinking (Littauer

1992). The results showed the type of personality of

respondents is more with type choleric, followed by

phlegmatic, sanguine and melancholy. Choleric

tends to be more at a chronic sorrow state of

pervasive state, followed by a permanent, periodic

and potentially progressive state. The same things

also happen with personality type of sanguine and

melancholy. But the phlegmatic personality type is

more at pervasive state then followed by periodic,

permanent and potentially progressive state.

Subjective health is something that individuals

perceive about their own health at a given point in

time (Johnston et al. 2009). Subjective health in term

of utility scale is highly desirable and useful for

economic evaluation of treatments and medical

procedures (Feeny et al. 1996). The results show the

tendency of “Good” category which is more than

“Poor”. On the results of good subjective health tend

to be more on pervasive state and followed by

permanent and periodic state and without any

chronic sorrow at potentially progressive state. In

the results of poor subjective health tend to be more

in the permanent and periodic state, followed by

potentially progressive state and the last is the

pervasive state.

Self-ideal is the individual’s perception of how

he or she should behave based on certain standards,

aspirations, goals or personal judgments. Standard

can relate to the type of a number of aspirations,

purpose, values to be achieved. Self-ideal will create

the ideals and personal expectations based on social

norms (family culture) and to who wants to do

(Stuart & Sundeen 1991). The results show that

positive self-ideal tends to be more on the pervasive

chronic sorrow state then followed by permanent

and periodic state and without chronic sorrow at

potentially progressive state. On the negative self-

The 9th International Nursing Conference 2018 607

“Nurses at The Forefront in Transforming Cre, Science, and research”

ideal tend to be more at permanent stage of chronic

sorrow, followed by pervasive state and the last is at

potentially progressive state.

Self-image is a person’s attitude towards their

body consciously and unconsciously. This attitude

includes perceptions and feelings about the size,

shape of present and potential body function that are

continuously modified with new experiences of each

individual (Stuart & Sundeen 1991). Since born, an

individual explored their body parts, received stimuli

from others, then begin to manipulate the

environment and begin to realize their selves apart

from the environment. The way of individual sees

their selves have an important impact on their

psychological aspect. A realistic view of their selves

in receiving and measuring parts of their body will

increase the sense of comfort and avoid the anxiety

(Keliat 1992). The results showed that positive self-

image tends to be more on the pervasive chronic

sorrow state and then followed by permanent and

periodic state and without chronic sorrow at

potentially progressive state. In negative self-image

is more at permanent state of chronic sorrow,

followed by periodic and potentially progressive

state, the last is at pervasive state.

Self-esteem is a personal judgment as the results

that achieved by analyzing how far the ideal self-

fulfilling behavior (Stuart & Sundeen 1991). The

frequency of goal attainment will result in low or

high self-esteem. If individuals often fail, they tend

to have lower self-esteem. Self-esteem is obtained

within their self and from others. The main aspect is

to be loved and receive appreciation from others

(Keliat 1992). The results showed that positive self-

esteem tends to be more at chronic sorrow state of

pervasive then followed by permanent, periodic and

potentially progressive state. Negative self-esteem is

more at periodic state of chronic sorrow, and then

followed by permanent, potentially progressive and

pervasive state.

5 CONCLUSIONS

Pakurenan culture (extended family) in Indonesia

show a chronic sorrow image that tends to be more

frequent in mild conditions (pervasive) and very few

at severe state. This means that the culture of

Pakurenan is very good at maintaining chronic

sorrow which experienced by elderly due to their

loss of partner, so that chronic sorrow could be

easier to be handled.

This study also explores how the characteristic

of respondents related to chronic sorrow

experienced. Conditions of chronic sorrow

experienced by the elderly who lost their partner are

strongly related to age, gender, personality type,

subjective health, self-ideal, self-image, and self-

esteem. Women elderly experience more chronic

sorrow due to loss of partner the men. Older age also

showed better chronic sorrow state than younger

ages. Sanguine and melancholy personality types

tend to display milder chronic sorrow state but the

choleric and phlegmatic personality types tend to be

more in the mild to moderate range. Subjective

health, self-ideal, self-image and self-esteem showed

the same thing that good subjective health, positive

self-ideal, positive self-image and positive self-

esteem tend to display milder state of chronic

sorrow.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The authors wish to thank the participants and

agencies which supported this research.

REFERENCES

Adnyani, N.K.S., 2016. Bentuk Perkawinan Matriarki pada Masyarakat Hindu Bali Ditinjau dari Perspektif Hukum Adat dan Kesetaraan Gender. Jurnal Ilmu Sosial dan Humaniora , 5(1), pp.754–769. Brenn, T. & Ytterstad, E., 2016. Increased risk of death immediately after losing a spouse: Cause-specific mortality following widowhood in Norway. Preventive Medicine , 89, pp.251–256. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ypmed.2016.06.019. Cash, T.F., Winstead, B.W. & Janda, L.H., 1986. The great American shape-up: Body image survey report. Psychology Today , 20(4), pp.30–37. Dorland, 2012. Dorland’s Pocket Medical Dictionary 29th ed., Philadelphia: Saunders. Eakes, G.G., Burke, M.A. & Hainsworth, M.A., 1998. Middle-Range Theory Of Chronic Sorrow. Journal of Nursing Scholarship , 30(2), pp.179–184. Feeny, D., Torrance, G. & Labelle, R., 1996. Integrating Economic Evaluations and Quality of Life Assessments. In B. Spilker, ed. Quality of Life and Pharmacoeconomics in Clinical Trials. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven,. Fried, E.I. et al., 2015. From loss to loneliness: The relationship between bereavement and depressive symptoms. Journal of abnormal psychology , 124(2), pp.256–265. Fry, P.S., 2001. Predictors of health-related quality of life perspectives, self-esteem, and life satisfactions of older adults following spousal loss: an 18-month follow-up study of widows and widowers. The Gerontologist , 41(6), pp.787–798. Hajek, A. et al., 2017. Factors affecting functional impairment among elderly Germans - Results of a